Lately, there’s been a lot of discussion about how progressive the federal income tax should be given rapidly rising levels of economic inequality in the United States. The debate typically finds liberals arguing for a more progressive system with increases in the top rate and perhaps an increase in the number of tax brackets to better reflect gradations among the wealthiest taxpayers. I’m on board with more progressivity, but I keep thinking about this post/chart from Lane Kenworthy:
The [above] chart shows the amount of inequality reduction achieved by taxes and by government transfers (social security payments, unemployment benefits, the Earned Income Tax Credit, and so on) in the United States and nine other rich countries. The calculations are mine, using data from the Luxembourg Income Study database, which provides the best available comparative data on incomes. Inequality is measured using the Gini coefficient. I calculate inequality in each country using household incomes before and after taxes are subtracted; the difference between the two is the amount of inequality reduction achieved by taxes. I do the same for government transfers. Being farther to the right in the chart indicates greater reduction of inequality.
Prof. Kenworthy’s conclusion is that the “tax” part of “tax and spend” does very little to reduce inequality. The US tax system is slightly more progressive than what’s found in OECD counterparts, but in all cases the egalitarian effects are modest.
It’s the spending that’s doing the heavy lifting. Which makes sense: even universal programs like Social Security, unemployment insurance, and Medicare that we normally don’t include in the US definition of “welfare” have a redistributional effect. The difference between the US and more egalitarian countries isn’t how progressive taxes are, but the quantity of taxes collected and the the generosity of the programs those taxes fund.
From this, Kenworthy concludes that liberals should support a national consumption tax to fund initiatives like “universal preschool, and/or high-quality child care.” Maybe! But if we’re going to spend outrageous amounts of political capital convincing voters of the need for more revenue, we should really kill two birds with one stone and make the tax incident on carbon-intensive activities rather than on any kind of consumption. Market-based environmentalism + egalitarian transfers = success. Something to consider.
This is a great example on how the redistribution of wealth (taken by the government from taxpayers to subsidize the poor) can reduce inequality. I just wish we weren’t terrified of the word “redistribution”.
It’s not the word “redistribution” that Americans are afraid of. After all, we’ve been redistributing the wealth in this country upward for over 30 years now.
No the problem in this country is one of false expectations. People are told that if they just work hard enough, one day they too will be rich. So, in the interest of planning for their own future, they don’t want taxes on the rich to be too high because when their ship comes in they don’t want to pay those taxes. Unfortunately, reality does not agree with their expectations. The overwhelmingly vast majority of people born into poverty will stay there for their entire lives, and they are stuck in this positive feedback loop of bullshit that the rich & powerful in this country have been shoveling for generations.
tags: | #economics | #politics
- regioninhabi likes this
- edhardy-clothing likes this
- silas216 reblogged this from ilyagerner
- silas216 likes this
- externalities likes this
- taylorhowlett likes this
- sarahlee310 likes this
- hcdragon likes this
- fsufeministalumna likes this
- citizenkerry likes this
- existentialcrisisfactory likes this
- treatyoselfartie reblogged this from drinkthe-koolaid
- treatyoselfartie likes this
- mostfleetingofall likes this
- asunkee reblogged this from ilyagerner and added:
- sp-a-m likes this
- azspot likes this
- drinkthe-koolaid reblogged this from jonathan-cunningham and added:
- asunkee likes this
- drinkthe-koolaid likes this
- justamandanotahero reblogged this from jonathan-cunningham
- femonster likes this
- hungryghoast likes this
- voorwaarts likes this
- coldbloodedboy reblogged this from jonathan-cunningham and added:
- jonathan-cunningham reblogged this from ilyagerner and added:
- jonathan-cunningham likes this
- bradleywarshauer likes this
- ilyagerner likes this
- afeldman likes this
- manicchill reblogged this from ilyagerner and added:
- purns likes this
- gonzodave likes this
- redlightpolitics likes this
- pantslessprogressive likes this
- This was featured in #Politics
- thepoliticalnotebook likes this
- ilyagerner posted this